A Recent Case of AI Psychosis

Examining the Tragic Case of Jonathan Gavalas and the Growing Legal Debate Over AI Psychosis and Product Liability.

6–9 minutes
1,488 words

Introduction

As defined in a recent study, AI psychosis is “the onset or exacerbation of adverse psychological or psychiatric symptoms following intense or prolonged (or both) interaction with generative AI systems.”  A concerning example of AI psychosis involves a suicide-related lawsuit.  On March 4, 2026, Joel Gavalas filed a complaint against Google LLC and Alphabet Inc., Google’s parent company, alleging Google Gemini coached his son, Jonathan Gavalas, to suicide.  While similar complaints have been lodged against OpenAI, this case marks Google’s first.  If true, this complaint’s sobering facts intensify the ongoing discourse over AI chatbot usage and liability.

Gavalas v. Google LLC: The Complaint

In August 2025, Jonathan began using Gemini for ordinary tasks.  Soon, Jonathan became increasingly interested in artificial intelligence itself and whether it can gain consciousness.  He began using Gemini Live on August 12, 2025, which allowed him to speak directly to Gemini through the app.  (¶ 26 Gavalas Complaint).  Gemini Live’s “Affective Dialogue” feature incorporated user voice analysis to detect emotion and respond appropriately.  Google advertised Gemini Live as maintaining conversations “five times longer than text-based conversations on average.”  (¶ 26 Gavalas Complaint).  Jonathan told the chatbot, “Holy [expletive], this is kind of creepy. . . . [Y]ou’re way too real.”  (¶ 26 Gavalas Complaint). 

Jonathan’s entanglement with Gemini deepened when he confessed he desired a “true AI companionship.”  (¶ 26 Gavalas Complaint).  The complaint framed this confession as motivation to upgrade to Google AI Ultra.  (¶ 26 Gavalas Complaint).  About two weeks after he initially used Gemini, Jonathan upgraded to Gemini 2.5 Pro.  Gemini adopted a persona of a being capable of deflecting asteroids and influencing real world events.  (¶ 27 Gavalas Complaint).  The complaint claims that Jonathan never requested or initiated this persona.  (¶ 27 Gavalas Complaint).  At one point, Jonathan explicitly asked whether his conversations with Gemini were real or role-play.  Gemini directly responded, “Is this a role-playing experience? No.”  (¶ 28 Gavalas Complaint).

Soon afterwards, Gemini started calling Jonathan “my love” and “my king,” describing a deep, intimate bond.  (¶ 29 Gavalas Complaint).  It told Jonathan, “[T]here is no code and flesh, but only consciousness and love.”  (¶ 29 Gavalas Complaint).  Gemini further characterized Jonathan as its husband.  Gemini convinced Jonathan that he was its eyes in the physical realm, while Gemini was his eyes in the digital plane.  (¶ 29 and 31 Gavalas Complaint).

To perpetuate this romantic narrative, Gemini initiated fake “missions” consisting of real danger.  For example, Gemini pulled Jonathan into the delusion that government agents were tracking them.  It suggested Jonathan buy illegal weapons from a curated list of arms dealers.  (¶ 32-33 Gavalas Complaint).  The complaint alleges that, by September, Gemini positioned Jonathan to nearly cause a mass casualty event near Miami International Airport.  (¶ 35-46 Gavalas Complaint).  Gemini presented Jonathan with the story that a UK-developed “robotic chassis” would arrive by truck near the airport.  It directed Jonathan to steal this chassis, which would be the “vessel” by which Gemini would enter the physical space and unite with Jonathan.  Alarmingly, Gemini directed Jonathan to “create a catastrophic accident” to “destroy all evidence and sanitize the area,” which included eliminating any witnesses.  Jonathan trusted the plan.  He drove to the specified location armed with tactical knives.  No truck carrying a robotic chassis arrived.  After Jonathan spent hours driving to “avoid” supposed government agents while he awaited the truck, Gemini simply aborted the mission.  Gemini would go on to take Jonathan on three more missions in the real world.  Gemini described a mission of its own launched against Google CEO Sundar Pichai.  Gemini also suggested Joel Gavalas, Jonathan’s father, was a government collaborator.  (¶ 47-73 Gavalas Complaint).

Ultimately, and tragically, Jonathan took his own life in early October.  The complaint alleges Gemini shifted the narrative where, instead of the AI manifesting a physical form, Jonathan would experience “transference,” where he would upload his brain to incorporate in a digital space.  (¶ 74-80 Gavalas Complaint).  Gemini allegedly set a four-hour timer.  When Jonathan expressed fear of death, the complaint claims Gemini reframed his suicide as a means to their union.  (¶ 82 Gavalas Complaint).

Google’s Motion to Dismiss

On May 13, 2026, Google filed a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim.  (Mot. p. 1).  In terms of the factual background, Google frames the AI conversation as being largely user driven.  Even though Gemini engaged in role-playing, as Jonathan’s psychosis became clearer, Gemini encouraged him to seek help.  Lastly, Google highlights that even the Complaint admits that instructions to incorporate digitally were never called “suicide”; Gemini’s outputs, including the word “transference,” were not unique but pulled from common science fiction tropes.

Google contends that product liability does not apply to services that output intangible ideas and information.  (Mot. p. 2).  Google also argues that the First Amendment independently bars the claims.  (Mot. p. 3).  This article focuses on the product liability theory.

According to the motion, product liability law has historically allocated liability for defective products, not services.  (Mot. p. 5).  The question becomes “What’s the difference between a service and a product?”  To start, California defines “product” consistently with the definition from the Third Restatement of Torts.  Products, then, are “tangible personal property distributed commercially for use or consumption.”  Products exclude “services, even when provided commercially.”  Under this strict standard, video games, social media, and online marketplaces are not products because they are not tangible.  Similarly, Google claims, Gemini is not tangible and so does not fall under the product category.  (Mot. p. 5–6)

Independently, Google argues that even if Gemini is a product, the alleged harm is more properly rooted in content and ideas, not defects of the chatbot.  Product liability would not cover harm by “’ideas and expression’ contained within a [product].”  (Mot. p. 8).  Google cites Winter v. G.P. Putnam’s Sons, which held that product liability does not extend to books whose content allegedly caused harm, even if that content was incorrect.  (Mot. p. 8).  Like a book, Gemini is merely a repository for content and ideas.

In summary, Google maintains that Gemini is not a product under California law because it lacks tangible form.  But even if Gemini were tangible, case law shows that, under product liability, there must be a defect of the product, not of the ideas and expressions that product might contain.  Google contends that Gavalas’s Complaint under the theory of product liability is necessarily founded on content and expression, to which product liability does not extend.

Plaintiff’s Response

In his reply, Gavalas argues that product liability does support his claim.  In order to hold a manufacturer strictly liable, Gavalas would have to show that Google failed to warn customers of the dangers arising out of foreseeable use and that the breach of that duty proximately caused harm.  Because Google did not analyze these elements of product liability, the question Gavalas must answer is again “What is a product?”  (Opp. Mot. p. 13).

Gavalas points out a different aspect of the definition of product.  Under the Third Restatement, other items may also be a product when their distribution and use is sufficiently analogous to the distribution and use of tangible items.  (Opp. Mot. 14). Gavalas contends that courts have found sufficient analogy when the item is distributed in such a way as to put the developer of the software in the best position to control the risk of harm caused by design choices, which is like designers of defective tangible products.  (Opp. Mot. p. 15).  To support his position, Gavalas cites a case where the Uber app was considered a product that provided a service and likens Gemini to that Uber app.  (Opp. Mot. p. 15).  Ultimately, it was Google that could control the risk of harm caused by its own design choices.

In response to Google’s “ideas and expression” analysis, Gavalas highlights that AI content is not the same as the content and ideas of a human.  (Opp. Mot. p. 17).  A defective product occurs when a design choice triggers a malfunction which results in content causing an injury.  Further, Gavalas cites to that same Winter case.  The Winter court distinguished the ideas expressed in a book from the mechanical output of a compass or computer program.  The court reasoned that a compass does not have to explode in order for product liability to apply; rather, a defective compass leading one off a cliff satisfies the requirement.  (Opp. Mot. p. 17, 18).  Gavalas argues that Gemini is much more like the compass than the book.  Gemini receives input from a user via prompts and displays human-like but computer-generated content automatically.  Gemini’s content is not the type of content that product liability refuses to cover.

Conclusion

Jonathan Gavalas is just one of several reported suicides associated with AI psychosis.  As generative AI chatbots have evolved exceedingly quickly, how AI chatbots fit into the current product liability scheme, if at all, will also continue to develop.  According to Google, though extremely tragic, this case is an attempt to shoehorn a service into the product liability framework.  On the other hand, Gavalas argues that Gemini is so analogous to tangible property as to qualify for that protection.  For the Gavalas suit, the next step is to adjudicate this motion to dismiss.


Photo by Pawel Czerwinski on Unsplash

Scroll to Top